"I find the hand wringing to be hyperbolic."
I find you unaware of situations which don't match yours. You would've purged my late MIL from the rolls.
"How do people drive automobiles on the street legally without renewing their registration on a yearly basis, and in some states go get a safety inspection."
My late MIL hadn't driven for a decade when I met her.
"How do people get new licenses when they move?"
She never used one again. Her state license had long expired.
"How about a new phone?"
No one asked for her ID when we bought her a phone.
"Pay home owners insurance?"
After my FIL died, she moved in with us, and never paid homeowner's insurance. And I've NEVER had to show an ID to pay homeowner's insurance. Have you?
I prepped her taxes every year, and she signed them. Again, no ID required. Do YOU have to show your ID to file a tax return?
"Every election you should have to register for that election."
You're clearly an adherent to the suppressionists central lie: An additional barrier to voting won't be an additional barrier to voting. Regarding my MIL, I handled all her paperwork, and never saw a birth certificate. She was born in a rural hospital in the 20s, and you'd purge her for that. Of course, you're aiming for black folks, who'd have a larger percentage of missing paperwork than your average Trust Fund Baby.
"We keep the rolls, so the parties can send you election crap, that is what this is really about."
So in summation, you're barfing up situations where an ID isn't needed, and pretending that's somehow relevant. And nobody believes you care if political parties send out too many flyers. In reality, you want to purge the rolls of people who you believe will vote against you wanting more tax cuts...THAT's what this is all about.