Wednesday, January 15, 2025

Arrested by AI: Police Ignore Standards After Facial Recognition Matches

A Washington Post investigation into police use of facial recognition software found that law enforcement agencies across the nation are using the artificial intelligence tools in a way they were never intended to be used: as a shortcut to finding and arresting suspects without other evidence.

More

Arrested by AI: Police ignore standards after facial recognition matches Confident in unproven facial recognition technology, sometimes investigators skip steps; at least eight Americans have been wrongfully arrested. www.washingtonpost.com/business/int ...

[image or embed]

-- David Rosenthal (@davidros.bsky.social) January 13, 2025 at 5:27 PM

Comments

More: After two men brutally assaulted a security guard on a desolate train platform on the outskirts of St. Louis, county transit police detective Matthew Shute struggled to identify the culprits. He studied grainy surveillance videos, canvassed homeless shelters and repeatedly called the victim of the attack, who said he remembered almost nothing because of a brain injury from the beating.

Months later, they tried one more option.

Shute uploaded a still image from the blurry video of the incident to a facial recognition program, which uses artificial intelligence to scour the mug shots of hundreds of thousands of people arrested in the St. Louis area. Despite the poor quality of the image, the software spat out the names and photos of several people deemed to resemble one of the attackers, whose face was hooded by a winter coat and partially obscured by a surgical mask.

Though the city's facial recognition policy warns officers that the results of the technology are "nonscientific" and "should not be used as the sole basis for any decision," Shute proceeded to build a case against one of the AI-generated results: Christopher Gatlin, a 29-year-old father of four who had no apparent ties to the crime scene nor a history of violent offenses, as Shute would later acknowledge.

Arrested and jailed for a crime he says he didn't commit, it would take Gatlin more than two years to clear his name.

Gatlin is one of at least eight people wrongfully arrested in the United States after being identified through facial recognition. Six cases were previously reported in media outlets. Two wrongful arrests " Gatlin and Jason Vernau, a Miami resident " have not been previously reported.

All of the cases were eventually dismissed. Police probably could have eliminated most of the people as suspects before their arrest through basic police work, such as checking alibis, comparing tattoos, or, in one case, following DNA and fingerprint evidence left at the scene.

#1 | Posted by qcp at 2025-01-14 08:51 AM

Of course they do. If you're not held accountable you can do this.

#2 | Posted by fresno500 at 2025-01-14 04:33 PM

Drudge Retort Headlines

Mike Johnson Vows to Hold Aid to California Hostage (93 comments)

Tulsa Race Massacre Probe Finds 'Military-style Attack' (61 comments)

Early Momentum: Army Hits 30k Recruits, Half Its 2025 Goal (52 comments)

Trump Defense pick Pete Hegseth Grilled on Women in Combat Comments (41 comments)

Citizens United 15 Years Later (29 comments)

Newsom Signs Order to Speed Up Rebuilding After LA Fires (24 comments)

Trump: Create 'External Revenue Service' for Tariff Income (20 comments)

'I Think Things Are Going to Be Bad, Really Bad' (16 comments)

Schedule: Trump's Cabinet Picks Are Set for Hearings. (15 comments)

Steve Bannon Condemns Elon Musk as 'racist' and 'truly evil' (14 comments)