Monday, October 28, 2024

Which State Has the Best (and Worst) Polls?

FiveThirtyEight has some advice about predicting the winner of the presidential election: Flip a coin. In four of the swing states, the margin is less than 1 point; in the other three it is less than 2 points. The margin of errors on these things is typically 4 points or so, not counting methodological errors. With numbers like that, all seven could go one way or the other way and it could end up being a landslide in the Electoral College in either direction.

Posted by Hans at 02:35 PM | 3 COMMENTS | permalink

Comments

This raises the question of: How good are the polls? Actually, that question can be answered. Sort of. After all, there is a lot of historical data. In particular, 538 took a look at historical polling data and election results for president, governor, and senator in the swing states. Here are the results since 2016 (they also looked at earlier data, but they might be less relevant than the data produced since Donald Trump appeared on the scene).

#1 | Posted by Hans at 2024-10-28 02:36 PM

Clearly, the error is substantial in all cases, with polling in the Sun Belt states being better than in the Rust Belt states. This suggests we could be in for big surprises next week.

The article compares polling in the seven swing states to polling in other states. It is actually much better in the swing states. In Idaho, Oklahoma, South Dakota, and Wyoming, the average error is over 10 points. There is far more polling in the swing states than in these four, so maybe practice makes perfect"well, all right, less bad. (V)

#2 | Posted by Hans at 2024-10-28 02:36 PM

Graphics and charts can be found in the article itself.

#3 | Posted by Hans at 2024-10-28 02:37 PM

Drudge Retort Headlines

Trump's Racist NYC Rally (95 comments)

Trump Rally Speaker Calls Puerto Rico a 'Floating Island of Garbage' (65 comments)

Drop Box Fire in Tight HOR Race: 100s of Ballots Destroyed (36 comments)

Bezos Tries to Defend the Indefensible (25 comments)

George W. Bush's Daughter Barbara Breaks Silence on Election (25 comments)

'Put Them in Trauma' (23 comments)

Trump's Puerto Rico fallout is 'spreading like wildfire' in Pennsylvania (21 comments)

US Military Wrestles with How to Deal with Jan. 6 Trumpers (21 comments)