Well, I won't debate it. Except to call it rubbish.
But, back to the logic, my light-hearted answer would be something like:
Would I trust my computer if Linus didn't develop Linux and it just magically appeared?
I'm a Debian user. Ask any Debian user why they use Debian and they'll say "because it just works". So, yes.
Windows? ----, no! Mind or not.
If I was the Devil, I would make the souls believe they were in Heaven and let the realization they're actually in ---- set in slowly at first, until gradually making it undeniable.