Thursday, September 26, 2024

I Deserted from Putin's Army and the Ukraine War

Sarah A. Topol: After the invasion of Ukraine, a captain in the Russian army concluded that he had no choice but to flee the country with his wife. But they found that leaving Putin's Russia was more complicated than it seemed. This is a story told in five parts. Because of the security risks faced by Russian deserters, pseudonyms are used throughout. The photographs, however, are of the real-life subjects.

More

Comments

Graft was endemic in the Russian military, permeating every level from the top brass to the grunts. "The scale is astounding," said Sergei Fridinsky, one of Russia's chief military prosecutors. "Sometimes it seems that people have simply lost their sense of moderation and conscience." Theft was hard to root out, even if someone wanted to - it was less about criminality and more a mentality. The thinking was simple: It's one thing to serve the motherland, but you can't forget about yourself.

Pig was among the many commanders who stole state-subsidized fuel from the military and sold it on the side at the civilian market price. There were a number of methods for doing this - blatantly filling a commercial truck at a military gas station; filling a military transport, siphoning fuel from its tank to other carriers and then adding fake kilometers to trucks to explain the difference on the accounting end. Pig was also ordering his subordinates to saw wood from the base's firing range so he could sell it. Everyone did it.

Russia's turn-of-the-century prosperity had tapered off with the 2008 financial crisis and falling oil revenue. Though the government's official statistics suggest that poverty hovers around 10 percent, an investigation by the Russian outlet The Insider shows that the reality is much worse: Roughly half of Russian families in many regions live below the poverty line. Outside the major cities, more than 10 million people do not have gas in their houses; they collect wood for heating. Many families still do not have indoor toilets. They -------- in holes in the ground.

This is what posters like Effete wants America to bow down to. He plays Americans for fools and dupes because we don't know very much about Russia and how average Russians live and are exploited by their oligarchs and kleptocratic leaders, most especially in the Russian military.

This incredible story only reinforces that anything America can do to lessen the grip of Putin over Russia is a step towards liberation for the long-suffering Russian peoples. Though this story is about one man's tale of his experience in today's Russian Army officer class, his ultimate assignment to the Ukraine front, and his survival against the odds in executing an escape James Bond would be proud of, this is really an inside look at a Russia that is not what we've been told it is, though it's one Donald Trump would feel right at home in since naked theft and graft appear to be the national pastimes.

The link at the top (not the FB one) is a gifted one that anyone can read if they want to. This reads like a Robert Ludlum novel more than a non-fiction account of real lives lived under head-shaking circumstances. It's simply impossible to stop reading once you start. Trust me on this.

#1 | Posted by tonyroma at 2024-09-25 05:59 PM

Russia likes to make sure dissenters/deserters can never order take-out.

#2 | Posted by Brennnn at 2024-09-26 04:50 PM

I saved this for reading later - wow that's long.

#3 | Posted by GalaxiePete at 2024-09-26 09:28 PM

Related:

How Defense Experts Got Ukraine Wrong

The standard analysis of Russia and Ukraine paid almost no attention to the documented corruption of the Russian military, the rote nature of its exercises, and the failure of attempts to professionalize it. Far from having an abundance of well-trained personnel akin to American and British soldiers, Russian forces consisted for the most part of conscripts who had been bribed or coerced into signing up for a second year of duty in the same old abusive system. Many commentators wrongly compared Vladimir Putin's forces to their Western counterparts, yielding predictions that Russia would employ "shock and awe" against the Ukrainians - as if its air force had experience and organization similar to that of the United States. But the Russian military was not a somewhat smaller and less effective version of America's. It was a brutal, deeply flawed, and altogether inferior armed force.

The analytic failure in Ukraine makes a strong case for something so often lacking in military analysis and the academic world more generally: intellectual humility.

This deserter's story documents exactly what's articulated above as it regards the supplying and readiness of the average Russian conscripts and lower level officers.. Due to the immense corruption and criminality endemic to Russia's military, is it really far-fetched to ask whether their nuclear arsenal might be more of another Potemkin village in pieces and parts as well?

#4 | Posted by tonyroma at 2024-09-27 09:27 AM

Do you want to Risk the Future of Humanity and the Biosphere itself on the possibility that Russia is a "Potemkin Village"?

Because Some Guy was Disgruntled. Plenty of Americans are Disgruntled Too.

Military Veterans Kill themselves Every Day. That's Disgruntlement.

So What if this guy Hates the Russian Military.

I Hate the American Military.

Am I Reflective of Mainstream America?

Based on my beliefs as posted here?

#5 | Posted by Effeteposer at 2024-09-27 06:02 PM

Zelenskyy meets with Putin ambassador.

www.cbsnews.com

#6 | Posted by reinheitsgebot at 2024-09-27 09:53 PM

Drudge Retort Headlines

Gaetz Withdraws (65 comments)

Gaetz Sent over $10K in Venmo Payments to Women who Testified (33 comments)

Mike Johnson Institutes Transgender Bathroom Ban for U.S. House (30 comments)

RFK Jr. Compared Trump to Hitler (25 comments)

Pam Bondi Picked for AG After Gaetz Withdraws (21 comments)

Poll: Americans Remain Divided on Key Campaign Promises (21 comments)

Nikki Haley Trashes Trump Picks RFK Jr. and Tulsi Gabbard (21 comments)

Hegseth's Sex Assault Accuser 'remembers saying no a lot': police (19 comments)

Arkansas Governor Proposes $6.5B Budget with Half Going to School Vouchers (17 comments)

Republicans on Ethics Panel Vote to Block Gaetz Report (17 comments)