Drudge Retort: The Other Side of the News

Drudge Retort

User Info

ocuser

Subscribe to ocuser's blog Subscribe

Menu

Special Features

Comments

The Republicans in Congress are at it again, trying to pass the SAVE Act (Safeguard American Voter Eligibility Act).

First, it would require that if your address changes, for whatever reason, even if you just move from one apartment to another, you'd have to repeat the process of registering to vote from scratch, no options to allow you to just update your current voter registration.

Second, you could only register to vote in-person, at a state voter registration office, so no more 'motor-voter' option.

But here's the big one: only three forms of ID would be acceptable when registering to vote; a valid passport, a certified copy of your birth certificate or your naturalization papers. Drivers licenses wouldn't count, not even a 'real ID', because it does not indicate your place of birth. Neither would a student ID, a military ID nor even a gun permit which has been used in some states, all because they don't show where you were born. In fact, the only 'photo ID' generally available to an individual which shows your place of birth is your passport, and less than half of the citizens of the US has ever been issued a passport.

So if you don't have a passport, what do you have to do? You have to produce a 'certified' copy of your birth certificate. By certified, they mean it has to be one which was issued by your local records office and if must include an embossed stamp showing that it's an original copy. Xerox copes, FAX's or PDF's printed from the internet would not count, it would have to be an actual physical copy from the your local records office with the visible emboss present. And since it doesn't have a photo, you would then have to supplement that with something like a drivers license or state ID card. Which brings us to the next big problem. Married women.

The vast majority of American women take their husband's last name when they get married, which means that the name that appears on their birth certificate won't match the name of their supplemental ID, such as a drivers license or a state ID. This means that these married women would have to produce additional documentation such as a marriage license or papers from a court showing that they've legally changed their name. And lets not even get into what happens with women who've been widowed or divorced and have remarried, because they would have to produce a 'paper trail' to prove that their current name, as it appears on their drivers license or state ID, can be traced back to the name that appears on their 'certified' birth certificate.

And remember, this entire process would have to be repeated, from scratch, every time your mailing address changed, even if it was simply moving from one apartment in a building to another, or if you're a student, changing your dorm room. Or if you're in the military, getting reassigned to a new posting.

And ostensibly, this is being done to stop non-citizens from voting, something which happens so infrequently that you can barely represent if as a percentage of votes cast, something like 0.0001%, per a recent Brennan Center study.

OCU

#73: Exactly correct. During WWII, Americans in the homeland watching the newsreels or reading about our soldiers fighting would never know minorities were dying for the US. Look at Time or Life magazines from 1942-45, black soldiers, airmen, and sailors are not in any photos.

#75 | Posted by REDIAL at 2025-04-09 05:37 PM

The same thing happened during WWI, only in that case the big hidden group were Native Americans. At that time, Native Americans, who were born on reservations, were not considered to be American citizens. For most Native American men, the easiest way to gain citizenship was to serve in the US military, while Native American women could only gain citizenship by marrying someone who was already a citizen.

Well, during WWI, a significant percentage of the troops serving in France and Belgium were Native Americans and they suffered high casualty rates, which wasn't acknowledged until well after the war, but when it did become more widely known to the public there was a general outcry. Finally, in June 1924 Congress acted and passed the 'Indian Citizenship Act', also known as the 'Snyder Act', which granted citizenship to all Native Americans born in the United States, whether they lived on a reservation or not. However, Native Americans were still denied the right to vote in many states and it wasn't until the 1965 Voting Rights Act that Native Americans were given the full franchise as citizens. But until then, many 'anti-Indian' laws persisted in many parts of the county, with some New England states not only denying Native Americans the right to vote, but also not allowing them to own property nor operating a place of business, well into the 1950's.

OCU

Drudge Retort
 

Home | Breaking News | Comments | User Blogs | Stats | Back Page | RSS Feed | RSS Spec | DMCA Compliance | Privacy