Justice Amy Coney Barrett Recuses Herself in a Charter School Case

Wednesday, April 30, 2025

The justice will not participate in oral argument, deliberations or vote. She gave no explanation.

Posted by retort at 12:20 PM | 6 COMMENTS | permalink

The justices will hear a dispute this morning that could open the gates for public funding to go directly to religious schools. The case comes out of efforts to establish a charter school that would "fully embrace" the Catholic Church's teachings in Okla.[image or embed]
-- SCOTUSblog (@scotus-blog.bsky.social) April 30, 2025 at 10:00 AM

Comments

Perhaps she is in favor of it, but does not want to go on record as being in favor?

She likely knows it is likely to pass without her.

#1 | Posted by LampLighter at 2025-04-30 01:16 PM

Republicans never really believed in Separation of Church and State.

Republicans never really believed in the Constitution.

#2 | Posted by snoofy at 2025-04-30 02:24 PM

"a charter school that would "fully embrace" the Catholic Church's teachings "

Could you enumerate those "teachings" for the class?

#3 | Posted by LegallyYourDead at 2025-04-30 03:11 PM

This would allow the government to put its hand on the scale, as to which religions WOULD get grants, and which wouldn't.

Sounds like violating the Establishment Clause to me.

#4 | Posted by Danforth at 2025-04-30 03:15 PM

At its base, the teachings of the Catholic Church can be summed up as follows:
-love the Lord thy God with all your heart and all your soul
-love each other as yourself
-feed the hungry
-clothe the naked
-welcome the stranger
-visit those imprisoned
-be a voice for those who cannot be heard
-give up your belongings and take up the Cross

I find it very unlikely that such will be the message of St. Isadore School in Okiehomie. I also hope for the day--sometime soon after the SCOTUS rules in favor of this school--that Muslims somewhere in this country will seek a similar school charter, with Islamic tenets taught on the state's dime. Hijinks will ensue, with the hypocrisy and bigotry laid base...

#5 | Posted by catdog at 2025-05-01 12:35 PM

Religious and other private schools getting money is a necessity after Democrats completely destroyed the public school system. It is why Democrats send their kids to private school as soon as they can afford to do so - just ask Liz Warren how quickly she took her kids away from the 'poors' once she had some money.

#6 | Posted by ScottS at 2025-05-01 07:29 PM

Drudge Retort Headlines

Two Israeli Embassy Staff Members Killed in DC (62 comments)

Trump Tax Bill Will Cut Medicare (50 comments)

Are Democrats Fumbling a Golden Opportunity? (46 comments)

Deutsche Bank: U.S. Economy is Experiencing 'death by a thousand cuts' (44 comments)

Majority of US Companies say They Have to Raise Prices Due to Trump Tariff (40 comments)

Second Amendment Foundation Challenges Connecticut's Under-21 Handgun Ban (31 comments)

Mississippi Tornado Survivors Await Assistance from FEMA (28 comments)

Trump Confronts South Africa's Leader with False Claims of White Genocide (21 comments)

EU, Britain Add New Russia Sanctions Not Waiting for Trump (21 comments)

Trump Unveils Plans for 'Golden Dome' Defense System (20 comments)