"It is not for the government to make our lives better"
I will always remember this conversation:
Son: Why we do they paint the roads dad?
Me: That's a good question son! Why do YOU think they paint the roads?
Son: So we don't all crash into each other?
Me: That's right son! That's right!
Yup. Time to grow up MasterTard.
The General Welfare Clause, found in Article I, Section 8, Clause 1 of the U.S. Constitution, grants Congress the power to lay taxes and spend money for the "common Defence and general Welfare of the United States". It is not a broad grant of power to regulate, but rather authorizes federal spending to address national issues, rather than local or private interests.
Come on. You are an adult now. Put away your childish things!
What do you think that "General Welfare" means. It has a specific meaning. You can do it! I bet you are as least as smart as my 12 year old was when he asked that very good question about the roads.
Refusing to obey an illegal order isn't an option in the US military; it's a requirement.
But it does take courage and bravery.
Here are some inspiring examples:
Hugh Thompson (My Lai): Thompson landed his helicopter between American soldiers and fleeing civilians, ordering his crew to shoot at fellow soldiers if they continued to kill civilians.
Michael Jackson (Kosovo): British General Mike Jackson refused a direct order from U.S. General Wesley Clark to block Russian troops at Pristina Airport, stating he would not start "the Third World War".
Soldiers at My Lai: Multiple soldiers under Lt. Calley's command disobeyed implicit or explicit orders to participate in the mass murder and rape of civilians by refusing to participate in the killings.
Legal Duty to Disobey: Service members are legally required to obey lawful orders, but MUST refuse illegal orders"those violating the Constitution, U.S. law, or international law (such as the Geneva Conventions).
"Following Orders" Defense: "I was just following orders" is not a valid defense against war crimes.