Drudge Retort: The Other Side of the News
Wednesday, March 11, 2026

Why America is Losing the War With Iran (w/ John Mearsheimer) | The Chris Hedges Report

More

Alternate links: Google News | Twitter

To be perfectly clear the American military can destroy anything it sets it mind to.

The essential problem is that America (and Israel) ABSOLUTELY cannot institute regime change without a ground invasion. Iran has the capability to withstand a sustained air attack. This is not Gaza where 2 million people are penned into an area of the of Philadelphia with zero natural barriers. Iran is a vast mountainous country about the size of Alaska.

There is no way to destroy all of the rockets, missiles and drones that Iran has.

And be clear, Iran is winning the war of attrition. They are degrading the defensive systems in the gulf states, Iraq and Israel. More and more missiles and drones are getting through. The rate of interceptions is way down. 10% of missiles and drones got through early on now it is 25%. that means either the radar system is failing or the Iran has depleted the number of interceptor missiles.

This is CLASSIC small nation defending against large nation. An asymmetric contest where the attackers resources are split over a wide area, where the smaller force can pick or choose places to attack and cheaply wind down the larger force.

Furthermore, the attack on the oil infrastructure is HUGE. The damage Iran is inflicting is massive. Your news is hiding that fact, but day after day vessels that pass the strait of hormuz are suffering damage, I believe a freighter was sunk (or at least its crew rescued). Mining is very likely to have been done, which will take months to clear out. These attacks on shipping are done by cheap fast speed boats and they are getting through.

Combine the assault on the shipping with the fact that the gulf states rely on a constant flow of oil. They have limited reserve capacity, which when filled means the pumps are turned off and once the pumps are turned off they get clogged and restarting them takes a great while.

The damage to the oil "pipeline" to developed and developing nations has taken a catastrophic hit and will only get far far worse. Nations are taking band aid steps but they are all draining their reserves extremely quickly, surprisingly quickly

Ironically Putin is a prime benefactor of this between higher prices and lifting of oil sanctions. India's whole economy would have collapsed this week if Trump didn.t allow them to buy Russian oil.

Comments

Admin's note: Participants in this discussion must follow the site's moderation policy. Profanity will be filtered. Abusive conduct is not allowed.

Trump is left with very few cards to play. He can double down on blowing stuff up, but that will achieve nothing but a mounting number of civilian casualties.

There are only so many military targets to blow up. Look at this video

www.youtube.com

It shows remote desert missile launching that is impossible to detect. Iran is certain to have hundreds, if not thousands of these locations. Iran is not going to run out of missiles or drones any time soon.

So, Trump will blow stuff up for a few more days, weeks. But will achieve negligible actual reduction in Iran's ability to cause harm

There is also the question of Israel and their role. they clearly have different war aims then Trump does. How much can Trump prevent them from continuing the war. If Israel continues the war, Iran is not going to stop attacking the oil 'pipeline".

So trump has to force Israel to quit.

The problem is that he is a VERY poor position to do that or to force Iran's hands.

the bluster of increasing assaults every day or calls for unconditional surrender are laughable.

Iran has zero motivation to negotiate and critically have been shown that Trump is not to be trusted. America attacked Iran TWICE in the midst of negotiations (after the US unilaterally withdrew from an agreement). That is not going to make Iran want to negotiate. What agreement or guarantee can Iran rely on that Trump won't come back a year from now and attack again.

So, either Trump crawls to Iran to get some sort of face saving agreement (I honestly don't know what Iran would accept).

The alternative is ground troops and full scale invasion. The plans they have floated, seizing the nuclear material or seizing the oil terminal island are laughably stupid.

#1 | Posted by truthhurts at 2026-03-11 10:50 PM | Reply

Meanwhile every day brings danger of a world wide economic crash. It cannot be understated the damage that stopping that flow for a few weeks can cause. Nations entire economies rely on it. China relies on it. BTW we are pulling military assets out of S. Korea to protect the gulf. Will China see that as an opportunity? Who knows!

Oh and the Kurds have given Trump a big Fuck You to being the ground meat in a land assault. So the whole concept of a civil war blooming in Iran becomes a pipe dream.

Trump seems to be relying on a sustained bombing campaign and then declaring victory. But, really, seriously a bombing campaign achieves nothing. It would take a year to turn Iran into the Gaza strip.

So, you see, there is a major flaw in that argument of Trump declaring victory and moving on. Israel and Iran have a say in the matter. Israel could PROBABLY be convinced to stop, but what will force Iran to the table? Israel wants to bring the Iranian government to collapse to turn Iran into Iraq circa 2004. THAT AIN'T GONNA HAPPEN. But will a psycho like Netanyahu be convinced. Oh yeah, Trump gave Israel 20,000 1K pound bombs last week. That is enough ordnance for Israel for like 30 to 45 days of bombing. A campaign that long would destroy the oil market.

And, you might not get this, but Iran probably thinks they are winning. Of course they are taking a beating, but that is not how THEY measure victory. They define victory by the damage they are able to impact on the oil "pipeline", which is getting more severe every day. And every day the ability for the gulf states to defend against incoming missiles and drones is getting smaller and smaller.

So, yeah, I don't see any way for Trump to win this. There is a very good chance he will have to crawl to Iran to beg for them to stop.

#2 | Posted by truthhurts at 2026-03-11 11:00 PM | Reply

BTW a true ground invasion is probably the logical end point for Trump's "plans". But a ground invasion is well and truly a non-starter.

America simply does not have the number of troops for a true invasion. Not a special forces snatch and grab operation of the nuclear material say, but a ground invasion to truly overthrow the Iranian regime, ala Iraq.

But, you see Iran isn't Iraq.

First, Iran is HUGE and mountainous

Second, we have zero allies who will put substantial boots on the ground.

Third, access to Iran is only through hostile nations i.e. Iraq, Pakistan, Turkey, Afghanistan and we can't air lift 1,000,000 troops.

Fourth, Trump is a coward.

There are other reasons

But, my friends, this is where it gets scary

We have tactical nuclear weapons. I can envision Trump choosing that option over admitting a loss.

Not saying it is likely, but Trump wants to be a historical figure and all.

I can see Netanyahu whispering that is his ear.

#3 | Posted by truthhurts at 2026-03-11 11:07 PM | Reply

We have tactical nuclear weapons. I can envision Trump choosing that option over admitting a loss.

I wouldn't rule out Lewzer using strategic nuclear weapons. He's got them...

#4 | Posted by REDIAL at 2026-03-11 11:35 PM | Reply

Another consideration is that Iran is sending it's older missiles and drones to deplete the gulf state's interceptors.

Iran has hit a number of America's billion dollar radar installations.

As the war goes on Iran will be able to send more and more destructive missiles and drones with less and less defensive capabilities.

#5 | Posted by truthhurts at 2026-03-11 11:56 PM | Reply

Detailed article describing the success Iran has had against our defensive installations

mronline.org

TL:DR?

Iran has knocked out a substantial portion of our radar systems which guide the interceptor systems compromising their ability to track and intercept missiles combined with a catastrophic number of inceptors being fired that cannot be replaced quickly.

Not looking good for an extended fight

#6 | Posted by truthhurts at 2026-03-12 12:08 AM | Reply

Another consideration is that Iran is sending it's older missiles and drones to deplete the gulf state's interceptors.

That, if true, would be quite clever.

#7 | Posted by REDIAL at 2026-03-12 12:09 AM | Reply

Do not measure the success of the Iran war based on casualty count. It is not that type of war, yet. Plus the US is probably lying about casualties.

The measure is in interceptors and infrastructure (esp. oil).

#8 | Posted by truthhurts at 2026-03-12 12:09 AM | Reply

Duh.

Iran is playing a long game.

The US is being systematically pushed out of the Region piece by piece.

Israel is not TENABLE without Constant US Maintenance.

Maintenance that is being made More Expensive and Less Effective every Day.

Iran will "Win" if they make the US retreat and Israel is depopulated by people Running back to their Original Countries.

The Squatters are Evicting themselves.

#9 | Posted by Effeteposer at 2026-03-12 12:14 AM | Reply

Iran escalates attacks on Gulf energy infrastructure
By Victoria Gatenby
Reporting from Doha, Qatar

Concern is growing across the Gulf as Iran escalates attacks on regional energy infrastructure.

There was an attack on fuel tanks in Bahrain in the past few hours, while on Wednesday, drone strikes targeted fuel tanks in the Omani port city of Salalah. Also on Wednesday, a cargo ship was targeted by the Iranians in the Strait of Hormuz. Three sailors remain missing, while 20 were rescued by the Omani coast guard.

Now, the timing of that incident was interesting.

It came shortly after Trump warned Iran against targeting ships in the strait or laying mines.

The Iranians said they targeted the Thai flagged vessel because it had been ignoring their orders. They said all ships have to seek their permission to transit the strait and warned that the US and their allies will not be allowed to pass through that very narrow waterway, through which 20 percent of the world's oil supplies flow.

#10 | Posted by truthhurts at 2026-03-12 12:29 AM | Reply | Newsworthy 1

Winning is never the point (see Vietnam and Afghanistan). It's to squeeze every last dime out of the suckers and losers before you incinerate them

#11 | Posted by LegallyYourDead at 2026-03-12 02:17 AM | Reply

The following HTML tags are allowed in comments: a href, b, i, p, br, ul, ol, li and blockquote. Others will be stripped out. Participants in this discussion must follow the site's moderation policy. Profanity will be filtered. Abusive conduct is not allowed.

Anyone can join this site and make comments. To post this comment, you must sign it with your Drudge Retort username. If you can't remember your username or password, use the lost password form to request it.
Username:
Password:

Home | Breaking News | Comments | User Blogs | Stats | Back Page | RSS Feed | RSS Spec | DMCA Compliance | Privacy

Drudge Retort