Snoofy,
Only one yes, the "didn't oppose" is kind of confusing in your tally.
I would say no weapons until 25(hormones) unless ex-military, feel the same way about trans surgery. I believe a mag max is fine, but no laws on the number of mags you can carry.
It's also true that Originalism is only ever invoked by right-wingers, when they know the outcome they want, but they need to invent a legal rationale from whole cloth.
idk but it would seem to me having this as a "standard" is a good thing, even though you can search for your opinion in historical documents, in that it requires the court to go back and make an argument for their "rational" give some pre-post certification evidence as to why the opinion isn't just made out of whole cloth".
Kagan complains they are amateur historians, but really isn't that what a supreme court judge should do? Look up historical; text, opinions, rulings and interpret it to the context; the difference being the top court, there is no "stare decisis" that the lower courts could used to the satisfaction of the SC.
So they must look at history in some way.
The article you linked to clearly doesn't say any judge invents a legal rational from "whole cloth" .. ie a lie, but vary from traditionalist, or originalism, liquidation.
Also are you saying left-wingers are just making legal rational from "whole cloth"?
If not history, what should in your opinion be the "standard" the judges should use for their opinions? Their feelings? Marxism? Nazism? Or ?? what exactly should they base their opinions on?
Its really not a system of government if you base rights on "feelings" without some reference/argument someone in the past has used or made. "Originalism" encompassing "traditionalism", and "liquidation" seems reasonable for a stable society.
No, I hope one day that you learn to see beyond your own nose.
Short and snubby as it might be.
It appears that, after several disappointments, you clamped onto the worst sort of corrupt government policies that the world has seen since... 1930's Germany.