Scientific Accuracy of the Survey
Methodological Strengths: It represents one of the largest multi-institutional U.S. samples examining long-term satisfaction and regret among individuals who began medical transition during adolescence. The low regret rate aligns with a broader body of longitudinal clinical research showing high rates of psychological benefit and stability.
Statistical Limitations & Response Rates: Critics and commentators have pointed out potential limitations typical of retrospective and long-term follow-up surveys, such as non-response bias (i.e., whether individuals who dropped out of care or experienced severe adverse outcomes were less likely to complete or receive the follow-up survey).
Biases and Missing Context
Single-Clinic / Specialized Cohort Bias: The participants were drawn from specialized, multidisciplinary pediatric/youth gender clinics. Patients who manage to access and stay with structured, comprehensive multidisciplinary care may have different support systems, socioeconomic backgrounds, or clinical trajectories compared to youth who seek care in different settings or face administrative barriers.
Loss to Follow-Up: Long-term survey studies of this nature often cannot track every single individual who originally initiated therapy years prior, meaning the denominator may not capture the entire population of people who started and subsequently stopped hormone use outside of the clinic's active tracking.
Definition of Regret vs. Discontinuation: Discontinuing hormone therapy does not automatically equate to emotional or psychological regret; people stop hormones for various reasons, including achieving desired physical changes, financial or insurance constraints, social pressures, or shifting identity labels. Conversely, some individuals may experience regret or mixed feelings that fluctuate over time.
via GIPHY